Dear Drew:
This is the hardest letter I have had to write. It grieves me to know that you were taken from us too soon. It grieves me to know that I never got the chance to tell you how proud of you I am, or how much I learned from you, or how much your fellow students thought of you. I can only hope you are at peace, again in your mother’s arms.
We sometimes – well, ok, frequently – argued in class. Some may have thought that we were trying to persuade each other; you were wise enough to see that my purpose was to help you think through your position, and ultimately be a better advocate. You wanted to become better and more articulate, and you did. As you did, you became more thoughtful, and deeper, better informed. And your inner kindness came to the surface.
It is conventional to think of mental health challenges in terms of people being pursued by “demons.” That is our metaphorical way of conveying that they are mysterious, sudden, uncontrollable, and terrifying. We say it because we cannot understand or explain what is happening. Those of us who do not have to live with them are often at a loss. Those who know demons live in fear of their reappearance, and a mix of despair and envy at the (blissful) ignorance of those of us who do not know. But how does one even put these experiences into terms others can understand? How do we help people who have these “demons”?
You came to understand, and to help me understand, that people are complex and difficult. Strictness and “tough love,” as tempting as they are, have no effect, no relevance, when the demons are in charge. Theory is no help. It is not as if all people work according to a single theory of human nature, or if any of us works the same way all the time. You figured this out, just as Aristotle figured it out long ago. I think that is why you continued to return to the Church, which long ago absorbed his lessons.
I am sorry I never got to say a proper goodbye. Perhaps that was for the best. Perhaps we shall meet again, in which case it would have been premature. But I wish you had stayed with us longer. And I wish you peace, wherever you may be.
Jack Barlow - Thursday November 08, 2018 via Condolence Message